
Tuesday 23rd was the day Melbourne’s live scene rose up and SLAMmed parliament house! A great rally from the State Library to Parliament house and it almost streched from end to end! I would say somewhere between 10-20k people where there, showing the support for Melbournes Live scene.
The rally, which I am sure you all know, was about the Brumby Governments liquor licensing laws that have jumped up recently, mainly due to voilence in the CBD, but also due to the state budgetry requirements - Nothing, I note, to do with live music venues, and any reasonable study would conclude Live music was the problem, but to quote xxxx “Music is the solution”
I was most interested to learn that Melbournians “care” so much about live music, and it is obvious that there is wide support for the industry in Melbourne. Muso’s, Publicans and Music Lovers appeared in droves to support the rally! Famous and semi-famous Muso’s where able to be spotted in the crowd along with the huge line up on the AC/DC tribute stage!
Let me firstly state that I am in no way supporting the Brumby decision to raise fees, and feel they are targeting the wrong venues with their laws.
The follow is controversial and does in no way reflect my opinion, it is simply objective and analytical.
I would now like to analyse “The Tote” closing and suggest some potentially unpolular ideas as to why it closed.
Firstly “The Tote” is a business, and businesses have a bottom line. Market forces, which we are so fond of in Australia, create and destroy markets for a product, in this case a venue that provides alcohol and entertainment to the public.
Melbourne, being the cultural and music capital of Australia has many of these venues, so the public has a lot of choice, not only in the where to go for live music, but also what else they could do with their hard earned cash.
I see trends in Society away from Pubs towards Bars and Clubs, I see trends away from “rock” towards electronic music, as well as trends towards the “latte lifestyle” especially in these inner city suburbs.
What I am suggesting is “The Tote” closed potentially due to lack of demand for its product, and that it was simply a lack of Demand for a product that is in oversupply in Melbourne.
The next point about the product “The Tote” offered; is it’s quality. As a venue “The Tote” was a bit scruffy, and in need of haircut, much like quite a few of the bands that played there I am sure. When you see new venues opening and surviving in the current climate, like Red Bennies, xxxx New Venue in Fitzroy, you have to wonder if it was the demand for the Quality of the product that was “The Tote” in combination with the higher fees that set it to close.
So blame the tools (Govt) or the management (supply) or the customer (demand) is the message I get from the closure, who do you think is to blame?
Some controversial ideas to think about.






